Home
Five homeowners insurance mistakes we see every week
The most expensive mistakes on a home policy rarely come from what's covered. They come from limits that look fine on paper and collapse under a real claim.
Most of the time, homeowners insurance does exactly what it says. The expensive mistakes aren’t about what’s covered. They’re about limits that look fine on paper and collapse under a real claim. Here are the five we flag most often.
1. Insuring for market value, not rebuild cost
Your home’s market price includes land. The land doesn’t burn down. Your dwelling coverage should equal what it would cost to rebuild your home from scratch at current construction prices, usually well above what you’d sell it for in the last few years.
2. Not scheduling valuable items
A standard policy caps jewelry theft at roughly $1,000–$2,500. One engagement ring can exceed that on its own. A scheduled personal articles floater values each item, removes the deductible for most losses, and covers “mysterious disappearance”, the industry term for items that go missing without a break-in or other named event.
3. Skipping water-backup coverage
Sump pumps fail. Sewers back up. Most standard policies exclude that specific kind of water damage unless you add water-backup as an endorsement. It’s usually $30–$80 a year and prevents a claim denial on what feels like it should be covered.
4. Leaving contents on actual cash value
Actual cash value pays what your stuff was worth at the time of loss, which is the depreciated amount. Replacement cost pays what a new equivalent would cost today. On a total loss, the difference can be tens of thousands of dollars. Most carriers offer replacement cost for a modest premium bump.
5. Accepting the default liability limit
Default personal liability often sits at $100,000 or $300,000. Most claims never reach it. But one serious incident, whether a dog bite, a pool accident, or a slip on your sidewalk, can blow past it quickly. Raising the limit is usually cheap; wrapping an umbrella policy on top is cheaper still.
If any of these sound familiar, it’s worth a short conversation before your next renewal. Our homeowners assessment walks through each of them in about two minutes.
